Umphrey’s McGee, Bevis Frond
Umphrey’s McGee – Guiness Oyster Festival, Chicago, IL 9/6/03 (video)
Umphrey’s McGee sound an awful lot like what would happen if Echolyn became a jam band. My first exposure to the band was a different video recorded by a bumpy camera that didn’t really do a whole lot for me, but this set was entirely impressive (and much better filmed). The band seems to exist on the shoulders of their two frontmen, both excellent guitarists and decent vocalists who, probably a lot like Garcia and Weir did in their day, trade spotlights. I’m not familiar with UM’s own music, which tends to hop styles like a lot of jambands – modern/indie pop here, jazzy jam there and the obligatory reggae number – but I enjoyed just about everything, laughing with pleasant surprise when the band segues effortlessly into Zeppelin’s “Fool in the Rain,” which has to be one of the most unlikely Zeppelin cover tracks. UM’s as terribly tight as you’d imagine from a jamband sort of tour schedule and there are loads of solo guitar spots, probably the closest thing on their repertoire to the scene they’re mostly allied with. Really cool stuff and unquestionably progrock.
Bevis Frond – Rockpalast, Harmonie, Bonn, Germany 10/6/04 (video)
Bevis Frond make me feel like I should like them a lot more than I do, at least up to the point of this video, where it sort of clicked for me what it was I don’t like. As you can generally tell from any of their concerts, Nick Saloman likes to talk and I do seem to remember anti-prog screeds and such in Ptolemaic Terrascope (and a previous DVD that I watched), which wouldn’t necessarily bother me except that such statements fall flat when his own songs seem so ambition-less. I’m constantly thinking, “another song based on a clichéd 3 or 4 note riff which sounds like what Jimi Hendrix would have been like if he couldn’t write.” Even things about Frond that I remember liking, the long 10-15 minute guitar bonanzas don’t seem to light me up like they used to, but perhaps some of the polish has faded over the band’s career. I do like the fact they’re using two guitarists for this Rockpalast show and that it’s all excellent quality, but I think I can safely say these guys aren’t for me.
November 29, 2007
|
Posted by MM
Categories: